Toni's Pizzeria

Photos

Reviews

1. Ramon Villarias ★★★★★

   Every so often, you encounter a remarkable local establishment. This time, it is Toni’s Italian Pizzeria in Pine Hill, North Shore Auckland. Primarily a take-away shop with a few tables, it operates without fuss or pretense—yet the results are anything but ordinary. The food is executed with a clarity and consistency that speak to genuine craft, and the service elevates the experience even further.

   almost 3 months ago
2. chris markov ★☆☆☆☆

   I really didn’t want to leave a negative review, but I feel like I have to. I was excited to try this place, especially being an Italian pizzeria. When you spend $30+ on a pizza made by someone from Italy, you expect a certain standard and care put into it. Unfortunately, that wasn’t the case here. The pizza was soggy, everything slid off, and it completely fell apart when trying to pick up a slice. I’m not sure whether it was the ingredients or the preparation, but it genuinely felt like there was no attention or love put into it. I had high expectations, especially after having pizza in Italy and other true pizzeria-style places, and this just didn’t come close. I ended up throwing it out after two slices. It’s really disappointing to spend that much money and feel let down. I would like a refund because this just wasn’t acceptable.

   almost 4 months ago
3. mrpeloquin ★★★★★

   I ordered a large four cheese and mozzarella sticks and it was handed to me just ten minutes later. Service is not only fast but very friendly too. Ripped into the pizza once home and it was superb… delicious, creamy cheeses complimented perfectly with a lightly spicy salami and set on terrific doughy base. Loved the Mozzarella sticks too. Highly recommended if you want proper pizza made with real fresh ingredients. Superb

   almost 6 months ago

1. Matthew G. ★★★★★

   If you’re looking for authentic Italian pizza in Auckland, this is the place to be! The dough is light, perfectly cooked, and the toppings are fresh and full of flavor — just like in Italy. You can really taste the quality and the passion behind every bite. The chef is not only highly skilled but also very kind and welcoming, which makes the whole experience even better. Definitely one of the best pizza spots in Auckland if you want the real Italian taste!

   almost 7 months ago
2. Alma Alma ★★★★★

   Very nice pizzas, they taste just like what you would get in Italy, which is a rare find in NZ! They also have a vegan cheese option and the dough is vegan, as it should be. The owner is friendly and it was nice chatting to him. Highly recommended!

   almost 7 months ago
3. greta monika ★★★★★

   The Tartuffo pizza is absolutely delicious. Pizza dough has the right thickness and crunchiness. You could taste the truffle paste, yum!

   almost 2 years ago

1. Ashi Ezz ★★★★☆

   The Italian Napoleon pizza served at the restaurant is both light and delicious, offering a satisfying culinary experience. However, it is important to note that the prices for this pizza are on the expensive side, which may be a consideration for those looking for more budget-friendly options. Despite the higher cost, the quality and taste of the pizza make it a worthwhile choice for pizza enthusiasts.

   almost 2 years ago
2. Tahlia RB ★★★★★

   One of the best gluten-free pizzas I’ve ever had! Was so delicious and as similar as you’ll get to a normal-based pizza. And of course, stone-fired are the best!

   almost 2 years ago
3. Sowmya B ★★★★★

   Had the best ever pizza! The base was incredible and the flavour was so so delicious. A homely little gem serving up authentic food. The tiramisu was a hit too! Will definitely be back.

   almost 3 years ago

FAQs