Sal's Authentic NY Pizza - Silverdale

Photos

Reviews

1. Neelesh Pillay ★★★★★

   I though it was going to be a bad American gimmick, turned out to be a really good American gimmick. The pizza bases are good and crispy, pepperoni was my favorite. The sauce on the Buffalo wings was up there with the best I've ever had. Will be back for sure.

   almost 4 months ago
2. Mark Guy ★☆☆☆☆

   We ordered a half/half pizza and two slices of another pizza. We got one half that was correct and the other half which was not what we ordered and not good. The extra two slices we ordered turned out to be just one slice! Incredibly poor service!!!

   almost 6 months ago
3. R G ★★★★★

   The best pizza I have ever had! The crust is thin and crispy, and the toppings are always fresh and flavorful. I especially love the vege pizza and Buffalo chicken pizza. The staff is also very friendly and accommodating. Bit pricy but still worth it Buffalo chicken $52 Vege pizza half $25.50 Mozzarella sticks x2 $14 each pack

   1 year ago

1. Alanah O'Flaherty ★☆☆☆☆

   Was burnt on the bottom. Very dry not fresh. Couldn’t change the pizza slice flavours in the combos apparently but can on Uber eats. Garlic knots were dry and burnt and flavourless.

   almost 2 years ago
2. David Smith ★☆☆☆☆

   50 minute wait time, man working behind the counter was rude. Went Sunday at 2:50 and didn’t get food till 3:40pm . Honestly big thumbs down. When your paying this much for pizza you expect good service.

   almost 2 years ago
3. Sue Yieu ★☆☆☆☆

   We both found the pizza too salty and smaller size than used to be. We wont be coming here again. Cheese sticks are smaller sizes than overseas but maybe its normal here. I dont feel the price is justifiable. Not much more expensive to go to an Italian restaurant.

   almost 3 years ago

1. George Barker ★★★☆☆

   Not worth the price. Not cooked enough. Big droop even with folding the slice. No leoparding of crust. Dough has ok chew. Pepperoni greasy and no spice at all. If you want to pay $33 plus for a pizza go to a restaurant

   almost 5 years ago
2. G M ★★★★★

   I ordered 2 pizzas online - I was told they would be ready at 7:14pm. I arrived at the store at 7:13pm...not ready...1 minute later I was handed 2 piping hot perfect pizzas. Awesome service - Awesome pizza with ingredients directly from Brooklyn. Yes, they are expensive, but they are also huge. I’m personally not a big fan of ‘genuine American’ anything these days but the team at Sal’s meet and exceed their promise - you get exactly what they say and if New York Pizza- thin base with tradition NYC toppings is your preference, then they do it to perfection. Now...where can I find a cheesy deep pan Chicago pizza pie..?

   more 7 years ago

FAQs