Sal's Authentic New York Pizza - Mount Eden

Photos

Reviews

1. Christina Wu ★☆☆☆☆

   Last Saturday, I placed an order for pickup at 7:40pm, but when I arrived at 7:45pm, staff told me they had forgotten about it and would need to make it then. I had to wait another 10 minutes in-store, while my kids were left hungry. There were no other customers in the shop at the time, so it clearly wasn’t due to being busy. What was most disappointing was the lack of any sincere apology or goodwill gesture—no offer of a drink or anything while we waited. Poor service and no effort to make things right. Will definitely go to the Domino’s nearby in the future, as they’ve never disappointed us.

   almost 8 months ago
2. Toby Cornege ★★★★★

   Sal’s Pizza in Mt Eden delivers a truly authentic New York-style pizza experience. From the moment you step in, you're greeted by the comforting aroma of freshly baked dough, sizzling pepperoni, and melted mozzarella. It’s the kind of smell that makes your stomach rumble and your expectations rise — and thankfully, Sal’s lives up to the hype. I ordered two classic slices: pepperoni and cheese. Both were exceptional. The pepperoni slice was perfectly crisp on the edges, with generous layers of spicy pepperoni that curled up slightly as they cooked, just like a real New York slice should. The cheese slice had a rich, gooey stretch and the tomato sauce underneath balanced it out with a slightly tangy bite. The crust was spot on — thin and foldable in the center with a nice chew, but still strong enough to hold the toppings without going soggy. The base had that beautiful light char underneath, giving it that authentic pizza oven flavor. What really blew me away though was the pepperoni wheel. It’s not just a gimmick — it’s a masterpiece. The dough is rolled around layers of pepperoni and cheese, then baked to golden perfection. Every bite gives you the perfect combination of soft, cheesy interior and a slightly crunchy outer layer. It's compact, flavorful, and ideal if you're after something handheld and satisfying.

   almost 8 months ago
3. Sterling Arnet ★★★★★

   it’s a passion of mine to check out all the Sal pizzas around New Zealand to see who can do the best Pizza and these guys have definitely got a good product going on here. food was served quickly and with great service no complaints here. Sterling Arnet Kakapo Business Sales

   1 year ago

1. Melissa Campbell ★★★★★

   If you're looking for the most "authentic" American (USA) style pizza... this is your place! Actual pepperonis and not salami like most places. Loved it!

   almost 2 years ago
2. Deanne M ★★★☆☆

   The pizza is great. Have ordered from this location quite a few times. The pepperoni wheels are always out of stock by 6pm though which is so frustrating. I think that has happened the last few times we’ve ordered.

   almost 2 years ago
3. Ian Rahardjo ★★★★★

   Always Love the NY style thin Pizza. The size is perfect not too big not too thick, the Pepperoni Black Garlic is a must try.

   almost 3 years ago

1. Ashlee Adams ★★★★★

   Sal’s is the BOMB! I was extremely sceptical at first - how good could chain pizza really be? We took the dive and ordered a range of goodies, including a half nonna, garlic knots and mozzarella sticks. All absolutely delicious! The total highlight for me was the blue cheese sauce which I’d heard amazing things about and it did not disappoint - creamy, tangy and just plain yum. Highly recommend ✨

   almost 4 years ago

FAQs